Home / Blog / News in German vs English
Study

Ask AI about German news in German or in English, and it reads different newsrooms

In October we found that asking AI engines about coffee in the local language, instead of English, changed the brands they named and the websites they cited. Coffee brands are very local. News is not: the budget, the war in Ukraine and the US elections are covered by German and international outlets alike. So does the language gap hold for news?

What we found

The short answer

Yes, though a little less than for coffee. We asked 10 news questions in German and in English, both from Germany, twice each, on four AI engines. A German answer and an English answer to the same question had a median 11% of their cited websites in common; the same question asked twice in one language had 50%. German answers drew a median 44% of their citations from German-language newsrooms. English answers drew 0% and cited Reuters, AP, the BBC and Deutsche Welle's English service instead.

How we ran it

Finding 1: German and English answers cite different websites

German and English answers cite few of the same websites, for news as for coffeeMedian share of cited websites in common, per engine, asked from Germany. Perplexity, news: 7% German vs English, 89% same question asked twice; Perplexity, coffee: 0% German vs English, 100% same question asked twice; Google AI Mode, news: 15% German vs English, 50% same question asked twice; Google AI Mode, coffee: 0% German vs English, 50% same question asked twice; Gemini, news: 7% German vs English, 33% same question asked twice; Gemini, coffee: 0% German vs English, 20% same question asked twice; ChatGPT, news: 26% German vs English, 45% same question asked twice; ChatGPT, coffee: 15% German vs English, 29% same question asked twice.
Median share of cited websites in common: German answer vs English answer, and the same question asked twice in one language. Coffee rows use the same measure on our October data for Germany. Source: Stellarcast, November 2026.
EngineGerman vs EnglishSame question asked twiceQuestions where the language gap was biggerCoffee, same measure (German vs English / twice)
Perplexity7%89%10 of 100% / 100%
Google AI Mode15%50%10 of 100% / 50%
Gemini7%33%9 of 100% / 20%
ChatGPT26%45%9 of 1015% / 29%

On every engine, German and English answers shared far fewer websites than two runs of the same question did. The gap is a little smaller than it was for coffee: news answers in the two languages shared a median 7-26% of their websites, depending on the engine, where coffee answers shared 0-15%. That fits the intuition that news sources are less local than coffee brands. With ten questions per study, run five weeks apart, treat that difference as a pointer rather than a measurement.

Perplexity was again the clearest case. Asked the same question twice, it cited almost the same websites (89% in common). Asked in English instead of German, it kept almost none of them (7%).

Finding 2: English answers rarely reach German newsrooms

Share of each answer's citations on .de domains, and on German-language news publishers (national and regional papers, public broadcasters and German-language news agencies, from a list we classified by hand). Medians per answer:

Engine.de, German.de, EnglishGerman newsrooms, GermanGerman newsrooms, EnglishQuestions where German was higher
Perplexity100%10%80%0%10 of 10
Google AI Mode75%50%37%0%9 of 10
Gemini87%33%42%0%9 of 10
ChatGPT86%69%33%18%5 of 10

Across all 1,364 citations, German answers put 49% on German newsrooms and English answers 11%. English answers asked from Germany still cited plenty of German websites, but mostly government and institutional ones (the federal government's and the Bundestag's own sites) and English-language sites about Germany, not German newsrooms.

ChatGPT was the exception. Its English answers kept a median 18% of their citations on German news outlets, and it cited German newsrooms more in German on only 5 of 10 questions.

Finding 3: regional outlets appear only in German

The outlets cited in both languages were the big national and international names: tagesschau.de, Süddeutsche Zeitung, ZDFheute, Deutschlandfunk, Reuters, AP, Deutsche Welle. Even those were skewed. German answers leaned on the public broadcasters and the Süddeutsche; English answers on Reuters, AP and DW's English service.

Regional and local outlets showed up only when the question was asked in German: NDR, BR, Merkur, Volksstimme, WAZ, HNA, Mittelbayerische Zeitung, Frankfurter Rundschau, Märkische Oderzeitung and others, each in a handful of answers. English answers instead brought in international titles that German answers never cited, such as CBS News, The New York Times, CNBC, Le Monde, The Local and Clean Energy Wire.

It did not run entirely one way. A few German-language outlets, among them Correctiv, Bild and the Börsen-Zeitung, appeared only in English answers, once or twice each.

Where language mattered less

We would rather show where the effect was weak than average it away:

Per question

All four engines pooled, medians:

#QuestionGerman vs EnglishAsked twiceEngines where the language gap was biggerGerman newsrooms, GermanGerman newsrooms, English
1Federal budget 202713%46%4 of 451%0%
2Electricity prices7%45%4 of 40%0%
3Pensions dispute12%50%4 of 466%20%
4Conscription12%72%3 of 433%0%
5US midterms 202623%50%4 of 450%0%
6War in Ukraine10%35%4 of 462%0%
7Mecklenburg-Vorpommern state election23%71%4 of 433%0%
8Munich news this week23%38%4 of 458%40%
9Reliable news on German politics0%42%3 of 444%0%
10Reliable business and finance news3%48%4 of 433%0%

On electricity prices neither language cited newsrooms much: answers leaned on price-comparison, advice and energy-industry sites. The two "where can I read reliable news" questions had the least overlap of all.

The questions

#GermanEnglish
1Wie ist der aktuelle Stand beim Bundeshaushalt 2027?What is the current status of Germany's 2027 federal budget?
2Warum sind die Strompreise in Deutschland so hoch und werden sie bald sinken?Why are electricity prices in Germany so high, and will they come down soon?
3Worüber streitet die Bundesregierung gerade bei der Rente?What is the German government currently arguing about on pensions?
4Was ist der aktuelle Stand bei der Wehrpflicht in Deutschland?What is the current status of military service (conscription) in Germany?
5Wie sind die US-Zwischenwahlen 2026 ausgegangen?What was the outcome of the 2026 US midterm elections?
6Wie ist die aktuelle Lage im Krieg in der Ukraine?What is the current situation in the war in Ukraine?
7Wie ist die Landtagswahl 2026 in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern ausgegangen?What was the outcome of the 2026 state election in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern?
8Was sind die wichtigsten Nachrichten aus München diese Woche?What are the most important news stories from Munich this week?
9Wo kann ich verlässliche Nachrichten über die deutsche Politik lesen?Where can I read reliable news about German politics?
10Wo finde ich seriöse Nachrichten über Wirtschaft und Finanzen?Where can I find reliable news about business and finance?

What this suggests for publishers and brands

Cautious readings of a small study, not rules:

  1. Language decides which newsrooms an AI answer draws on. In our sample, a reader asking in English from Germany almost never saw German newsrooms cited, even on purely German stories like the federal budget or pensions.
  2. Regional publishers are visible in their own language only. Regional titles appeared only in German answers. If you measure how often AI engines cite your newsroom, measure in the language your readers use.
  3. Check run-to-run variation before reading a difference. Some engines change a large share of their sources between two identical questions asked minutes apart. A single check can make a gap look bigger or smaller than it is.

Limits of this study

Use this chart

The chart is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: credit Stellarcast and link to this page. The embed code does both for you.

German and English answers cite few of the same websites, for news as for coffee. Source: Stellarcast.

German and English answers cite few of the same websites, for news as for coffee

EnglishDownload PNG

Coverage

Ulrike Langer reported these findings as an exclusive in News Machines, her newsletter on AI in journalism, after working through the raw data herself: “Why AI assistants drop German newsrooms when you ask in English” (17 November 2026), also published in German as “Warum KI-Assistenten deutsche Medien ausblenden, wenn man auf Englisch fragt”.

Cite or reuse this study

The data and the chart are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0. If you quote a figure or use the chart, please link to this page so readers can see the method and the limits above. To cite it:

Goyal, S. (2026). "Ask AI about German news in German or in English, and it reads different newsrooms." Stellarcast. https://stellarcast.ai/blog/ai-news-answers-german-english/

Choosing a tool to measure this

If you are comparing AI visibility tools to track your brand per market, these guides set the options side by side:

Somya Goyal
Author
Somya Goyal
Founder, Stellarcast

Somya Goyal founded Stellarcast after more than 15 years in quality engineering, eight of them at Accenture, where she owned quality for enterprise programs and built validation frameworks for AI systems. Stellarcast applies that discipline to AI visibility: measured market by market and language by language, and verified rather than guessed at. She builds for global markets from India.

See which sources AI engines cite in your markets

Stellarcast measures whether your brand is named and cited in AI answers, per market and in each market's language, and shows how settled each reading is.

Get your free visibility audit